The Amityville Legacy
Fifteenth Amityville film; a demonic monkey toy drives a father to murder.
Wikipedia / Wikimedia Commons
The Amityville Legacy, also released under the title Amityville Toybox, is a 2016 American horror film. Dustin Ferguson and Mike Johnson co-wrote and co-directed the project, which went straight to video. It marks the fifteenth movie inspired by Jay Anson's 1977 book *The Amityville Horror*. The lead role of Mark Janson is played by Mark Popejoy. His character is a father who, after being given a possessed cymbal-banging monkey toy that originated from the haunted house at 112 Ocean Avenue in Amityville, New York, turns to killing his own relatives.
The story begins in 1974 with Ronald DeFeo Jr. murdering his family at that same address. Forty years later, the Janson family gathers in rural Nebraska to celebrate the fiftieth birthday of Mark, a widowed and recovering alcoholic. He lives with his mother, Jeanne, who has dementia, and his pregnant daughter, Britany. The reunion includes his other daughters Julia, Jennii, and Breana; Breana's boyfriend, Daniel; Mark's son, Anthony; Anthony's boyfriend, Jade; Mark's sister-in-law, Cheyenne; and Cheyenne's daughter, Schuylar. Among Mark's birthday presents is the monkey toy, which was once taken from 112 Ocean Avenue. A demon inhabits the toy, appearing to Mark as his abusive, deceased father, Mr. Janson. The demon torments Mark—a devout Catholic—with visions, such as Breana and Daniel having premarital sex and Anthony and Jade engaging in S&M, each hallucination ending with the phrase "Stop me, daddy." The demon insists Mark must remove any threats to his family's unity, leading him to reluctantly kill Cheyenne, Daniel, and Jade.
After these murders, the demon tells Mark that eliminating the "outsiders" is insufficient. It claims his family members are all sinful and that Mark must "save" them by killing them to send their souls to Heaven. Mark then has a sexually explicit vision of himself and Julia. He arms himself with a shotgun and murders Jeanne, Schuylar, and all his children except Julia. During a struggle, Julia wounds Mark and escapes while he deals with two passing motorists. After killing those motorists, Mark gathers the bodies of his loved ones, stacks them in a room, and commits suicide. A week later, a psychic paranormal investigator visits the Janson house. The demon, now possessing a paperboy, boasts about making Mark kill his family and himself, implies it is the spawn of Satan, and kills the
- Release year
- 2016
- Country
- United States
- Genre
- Horror
- Directors
- Dustin Ferguson, Mike Johnson
- Lead actor
- Mark Popejoy
- Based on
- Jay Anson's 1977 novel The Amityville Horror
- Running time
- 66 minutes
Lore & Background
The demon torments Mark, a devout Catholic, with visions of premarital sex and S&M, each hallucination punctuated by the phrase 'Stop me, daddy.' The demon tells Mark he must eliminate threats to family unity, so Mark reluctantly kills Cheyenne, Daniel, and Jade. The demon then declares that killing outsiders is not enough and instructs Mark to 'save' his family by killing them to send their souls to Heaven. After a sexually explicit vision of himself and Julia, Mark arms himself with a shotgun and murders Jeanne, Schuylar, and all his children except Julia. Julia wounds Mark during a struggle and escapes while Mark kills two passing motorists. Mark then collects the bodies, stacks them in a room, and commits suicide. A week later, a psychic paranormal investigator visits the house, encounters the demon possessing a paperboy, and is murdered by vomiting up her own innards.
Reader's Guide
The Amityville Legacy is notable as the fifteenth film inspired by Jay Anson's novel, part of a long-running direct-to-video franchise. Its reception was mixed: Tex Hula of Ain't It Cool News called it a competently made fan film that comes to an abrupt end, noting its 66-minute runtime could have used another fifteen minutes. Dev Crowley of FanSided ranked it eleventh best out of fifteen Amityville films she reviewed, describing it as 'a whole lot sillier' than Amityville Dollhouse. The film's low budget and micro-budget production values are acknowledged, and it spawned a 2017 sequel written and directed by Ferguson, Amityville: Evil Never Dies (re-released in 2020 as Amityville Clownhouse). The film's plot centers on a demonic cymbal-banging monkey toy, a recurring horror trope, and explores themes of religious guilt and family destruction.
Did You Know?
- The film is also known as Amityville Toybox.
- It was written and directed by Dustin Ferguson and Mike Johnson.
- The demon takes the form of Mark's abusive deceased father.
- A sequel, Amityville: Evil Never Dies, was released in 2017 and re-released in 2020 as Amityville Clownhouse.
More in Amityville Horror films 1-24
Spotted an error? Know more?
This is a living reference — every entry is fact-audited, and reader corrections feed straight into our audit queue. Suggest an edit · See this site's audit record
